Sunday, March 14, 2010

Jewish Historian Saul Friedländer Defended Venerable Pope Pius XII

His Holiness, Venerable Pope Pius XII
*******
Jewish historian: Pius XII was not 'Hitler's Pope'

Rome, Italy, March 8 (CNA) .- In comments to the newspaper, "Le Point," Jewish historian Saul Friedländer defended Pius XII against accusations that he was "Hitler's Pope." Friedländer recalled that Pope Pacelli's aversion to Nazism was made known by his collaboration in the writing of Pius XI's encyclical, "Mit brennender Sorge."

Friedländer previously taught contemporary history at the University Institute of Higher International Studies in Geneva and also worked at universities in Los Angeles and Tel Aviv. He is the author of such books as, "Hitler and the United States," "Pius XII and the Third Reich," and "Reflections on the Future of Israel."

In the interview with Le Point, which was covered by L'Osservatore Romano (LOR), the Jewish historian referred to the silent work of Pius XII.

While some say he did little to protest the deportation of Jews and the Holocaust, written records and witnesses tell another story. They testify to his actions in defense of the Jews. Accounts of his intervention to save 4,000 Jews from a ghetto in Rome and place them in convents and Catholic schools refute claims of his passiveness.

In response to accusations against Pius XII's character, LOR pointed out, "Friedländer says he does not want to transform Pius XII into 'Hitler's Pope,' as others have done. Instead, he recounts Pope Pacelli's aversion to Nazism and his collaboration in the drafting of Mit brennender Sorge," Pius XI's encyclical condemning Nazi ideology.

8 comments:

  1. Gud day Fr.,

    Noynoy confirmed recently his support for the promotion of artificial contraception in general and the Rh bill in particular.

    What can you say about this father, since you appear to be pro noynoy?

    tnx

    ReplyDelete
  2. Good day too.

    I dont know where did you get your information. Just a few days ago all major newspapers reported that Sen. Aquino stated that he is a Catholic and he will upheld his Catholic Faith concerning the RH Bill. And the same news agencies reported the sudden shift of the senator's position on the matter.

    The Aquino Family is known and proven to be very loyal Catholics. That is why they are very dear to countless priests and nuns here and abroad. Even though Ms. Kris Aquino committed mistakes during the early part of her life but she has renewed her life since then and has been known as a very prayerful person together with her sisters. Senator Aquino is known as a good boy from his childhood, a model student, a model son to his parents and a Catholic just like the rest of his family. In fact, if he didn't run for the highest office I do not think that his Catholic stand will ever be questioned.

    So, I can trust this guy whose National Hero father died with the Holy Rosary on hand and was praying the rosay in his cell with his wife and kids than a Estrada, Gordon or Madrigal. I can trust Sen. Noynoy whose National Hero mother is considered as Saintly and was a partner of Cardinal Sin, Mother Teresa, Sister Lucia of Fatima and Pope John Paul the Great in upholding the Gospel of Life and in promoting the Holy Rosary. That I cannot say for a Teodoro or a Villar.

    Thus my vote will to to NOYNOY-MAR and not to the closest rival, a Billionaire who refuses to be investigated by his peers and is spending Billions just for political ads... a preposterous show of immorality. NO WAY.

    I can trust JC de los Reyes on his Catholic Faith but he is TOO INSIGNIFICANT IN THIS ELECTION. And I do not vote for insignificant candidates. I DO NOT VOTE FOR DON QUIXOTE DE LA MANCHA OF PHILIPPINE POLITICS. I think it is better for him to run first for Congress, then Senate before gunning for the highest post.

    IT'S NOYNOY-MAR FOR ME.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Sa mga Aquinos lang po ba tayo nakasalalay upang umusad ang ating bansa? Hindi po ba pwedeng ibang Pilipino naman po ang maghari at hindi lang mga angkan nina Cory at Ninoy. Hindi ba't sina Cory at Ninoy ay mga bayani ng bayan, hindi na sila pag- aari ng mga Aquinos. Lahat po ng Pilipinos. At hindi dahil sa hero na ang mga magulang niya ay hindi na siya pwdeng magkamali.

    ReplyDelete
  4. [Sa mga Aquinos lang po ba tayo nakasalalay upang umusad ang ating bansa?]

    Sinong nagsabi sa yo na sa mga Aquinos lang tayo aasa para umusad ang ating bansa? Ikaw lang ang nagsabi nyan. Hindi yan galing sa kin.

    Porke ba gusto kong iboto si Noynoy ibig sabihin non sa mga Aquinos lang ako umaasa? Nakakatawang pag-iisip naman yan. It doesn't follow and there is no logical link at all. Kung susundin ko yang pag-iisip na ganyan e di kung sino ang iboboto mo dun ka lang aasa. Mababaw na rason po iyan.

    Iboboto ko si Noynoy dahil sa tingin ko ay mas ikabubuti ng bansa ang pamamahala niya kesa mga mga Trapo na subok na sa politika. At malinis ang pagkatao niya. Walang corruption.

    Kung iba ang paniniwala mo e di OK lang. Di naman kita kinukumbinsi. Imagine, ang post na ito ay tungkol sa Pope tapos dito mo nilalagay ang tungkol sa politika.

    [Hindi po ba pwedeng ibang Pilipino naman po ang maghari at hindi lang mga angkan nina Cory at Ninoy.]

    Gusto ko rin ng iba. Kaso ang IBANG MAPAGPIPILIAN AY HINDI NAKAPASA SA AKING PAGSUSURI. Merong nakulong na sa pagnanakaw, merong Born Again preacher na nagpayaman at ang mga anak mga nasa Congress na, may dalawang unknown presidentiables na sure losers, isang taklesang Aristocrata, isang Bilionaire na labis labis gumastos ng pera at ayaw humarap sa paglilitis, isang tuta ng Bulok at Corrupt na Administrasyon, ang isa kunwari malinis pero sa Olongapo political dynasty rin at super yabang.

    BAKIT, ANG MGA ESTRADA, VILLAR, TEODORO AT GORDON AY MGA POLITICAL CLANS DIN NAMAN? ANONG CHOICE ANG IBIBIGAY MO SAKIN? SI NICANOR PERLAS? PWEDE BA. SI JC DE LOS REYS? NAKU NAMAN, AYAW KONG ITAPON ANG BOTO KO SA KANGKUNGAN.

    Hindi ba't sina Cory at Ninoy ay mga bayani ng bayan, hindi na sila pag- aari ng mga Aquinos. Lahat po ng Pilipinos. At hindi dahil sa hero na ang mga magulang niya ay hindi na siya pwdeng magkamali.

    ReplyDelete
  5. [Hindi po ba pwedeng ibang Pilipino naman po ang maghari at hindi lang mga angkan nina Cory at Ninoy.]

    SI NINOY AT SI CORY AY HINDI NAGHARI SA BANSANG PILIPINAS. SILA AY NAGLINGKOD.

    SI NINOY AY KINULONG, PINAHIRAPAN AT WALANG AWANG PINATAY. SIYA AY MARTIR PARA SA BAYAN AT SA KATARUNGAN AT SA KALAYAAN.

    SI CORY AY NANILBIHAN BILANG PANGULO SUBALIT HINDI TUMIRA SA PALASYO. NAMUHAY NG SIMPLE AT WALANG ANOMALIDAD. HINDI NAGHANGAD NG HIGIT NA KAPANGYARIHAN O MANATILI SA PUESTO GAYA NI MARCOS AT NI GLORIA. NAGING ORDINARIONG MAMAMAYAN MATAPOS ANG KANYANG PANUNUNGKULAN.

    SI NOYNOY AY PRACTICALLY THE FIRST GENTLEMAN OF THE COUNTRY DURING THE PRESIDENCY OF TITA CORY. SUBALIT HINDI SIYA NAKIALAM SA GOVIERNO. NAGING TAHIMIK AT SIMPLENG TAO. HINDI NAGBIGAY NG MASAMANG REPUTASYON SA PAMILYA AT SA BAYAN, DI TULAD NI IMELDA MARCOS AT NI MIKE ARROYO. BILANG CONGRESSMAN AT SENADOR, NANATILI SIYANG SIMPLE AT MARANGAL, MALINIS ANG PAGLILINGKOD. HINDI NAGHARI-HARIAN.

    HINDI SIYA NASILAW NG KAYAMANAN, KAPANGYARIHAN AT KASIKATAN. KAYA, NOYNOY-MAR TALAGA!

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hi fr.,

    I'm the one who first asked you about noynoy's position concerning the RH bill. Pwede ba paki post yung sabi mo na mga newspaper reports and their sources?

    Importante po na malaman yun nang maraming katoliko.

    Tnx!

    ReplyDelete
  7. Dear Anonymous,

    This Blog is primarily for apologetic purpose and for my pastoral activities. There are a few instances that I mentione Noynoy here but those topics have been buried in my archive. My posting of the NOY-MAR logo on top is simply my expression of my political preference. Take it or leave it.

    If you agree with it fine. If you do not, who cares.

    Now, I have given you enough time about my political views and that is enough. Let's just say that we agree to disagree. We are united in faith as Catholics but not in politics. Unless you are a member of INC.

    This will be your last post about politics here because the rest will not be posted anymore. At the time that I am bleeding responding to 120 questions from INC and ADD you are troubling me of politics to destroy the reputation of the heir of one of the most Catholic Families in the country. He has his limitations and weaknesses but he is not a traitor Catholic at all.

    Concerning the newspapers. You can google it or look for it in Philippine Daily Inquire or Philippine Star.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Pati ba naman paghahanap ng mga bagay na yan sa Diario e ibibigay mo pa sa kin. Pinagtatanggol ko ang Catholic Faith dito bunga ng sarili kong hirap at pawis at pagod. Hindi ko pinagagawa sa iba. Kung gusto nyong kumilos tungkol sa pulitika gawin nyo ang gawain ninyo.

    It is easy to collect all statements of Noynoy form the newspapers. Just Google them and they will appear. Do it yourself please.

    ReplyDelete